| 1967 number | Current number | Notes |
| 1 | 646 | Avondale Rd (now Park Ave) |
| 2 | 654 | Bay Ave |
| 3 | 506 | Belleville Ave |
| 4 | 506, Spur 506 | Bloomfield Ave |
| 5 | 663, 509 | Broad St |
| 6 | 640 | Bradford Ave - was this once Broadford to fit the system? |
| 7 | N/A | Broughton Ave, now town maintained (possibly 657 post-renumbering) |
| 8 | 508 | Central Ave |
| 9 | 631 | Central Ave, Grandview Ave |
| 10 | 527 | Cedar St |
| 11 | 648 | Centre St |
| 12 | 601 | Chancellor Ave |
| 13 | 614 | Clinton Rd |
| 14 | 665 | Clinton Ave, Irvington Ave |
| 15, 15A | 628 | Greenbrook Rd (15A in Fairfield, not sure why) - may be numbered based on East Greenbrook |
| 16 | 652 | East Passaic Ave - only built north of Hoover Ave [now 651] - followed original alignments (651 Spur and Sadler Rd) |
| 17 | 611, 659 | Eagle Rock Ave, Main St - not sure how far south on Main/659 it extended, out of order with 16 |
| 18 | 668, 623 | Elm St, Grove St - still ought to be the same number |
| 19 | 673 | Elm Rd |
| 20 | 615, Spur 614 | Fairfield Rd, Brook St - connected via NJ 159-US 46 |
| 21 | 637 | Fairview Ave |
| 22 | 645 | Franklin Ave |
| 23 | 670, 509 | Franklin St |
| 24 | 577 | Gregory Ave, Wyoming Ave |
| 25 | 509 | Grove St, Watsessing Ave |
| 26 | 639 | Grove Ave |
| 27 | 656 | Harrison Ave |
| 28 | 650 | High St |
| 29 | 638 | High St, Scotland Rd, Valley St (predates Valley St realignment at 57/510) |
| 30 | Spur 527/608 | Hobart Rd, White Oak Ridge Rd (newer name), Hobart Gap Rd |
| 31 | 651 | Hoover Ave |
| 32 | 626 | Horseneck Rd |
| 33 | 644 | Kingsland St |
| 34 | 634 | Laurel Ave - coincidence? |
| 35 | 604 | Lindsley Rd |
| 36 | 617 | Little Falls Rd |
| 37 | 602 | Lyons Ave |
| 38 | 527 | Mountain Ave |
| 39 | 642, 643 | Mt Hebron Rd, Alexander Ave - connected via Grove St/18 |
| 40 | 610, 577, 660 | (Old) Mt Pleasant Ave - both in Livingston and east of NJ 10 in West Orange |
| 41 | 618 | Normal Ave - not sure if this did or didn't follow Reservoir Dr like 618 now does |
| 42 | 508 | Northfield Ave/Rd |
| 43 | 577, 527 | Old Short Hills Rd, Main St |
| 44 | 669 | Orange Rd - same limits as current route |
| 45 | 606 | Parsonage Hill Rd |
| 46 | 629 | Pier La |
| 47 | 636 | Pleasant Valley Way, Lakeside Ave - may have ended at Old Indian Rd (original Mountain Ave) |
| 48 | 627 | Plymouth St |
| 49 | 577, Spur 577/677 | (Mt) Prospect Ave |
| 50 | 641 | Ridge Rd |
| 51 | 653 | Ridgewood Ave |
| 52 | 624 | River Rd - NJ 21 once used part of what's now 624, so 52 only existed north of there |
| 53 | Spur 527/649, 527 | Roseland Ave, Livingston Ave |
| 54 | 633 | Runnymede Rd, Lane Ave |
| 55 | 506 | Rutgers St |
| 56, 56A | 605 | Sanford Ave (56A north of 57/510 - may have been added later) - also shown as Sandford |
| 57 | 510 | South Orange Ave |
| 58 | 24/124, 603 | Springfield Ave |
| 58A | 527, 577, 630 | Millburn Ave - may have been a late takeover and thus no place in the grid |
| 59 | 616 | Stevens Ave |
| 60 | 619 | Stuyvesant Ave |
| 61 | 613, 661 | Swamp Rd, Passaic Ave, Pier La (now all part of Passaic Ave), and Beaufort Ave (this may have been an intentional renumbering) - see 62 and 61A |
| 61A | 607 | Passaic Ave - may have been intended to tie into 61 as what became Eisenhower Parkway/609 - see 67 and 61 |
| 62 | 613 | Two Bridges Rd (northern end of 613 - see 61) |
| 63 | 647 | Union Ave |
| 64 | 620 | Upper Mountain Ave - began randomly then as now |
| 65 | 621 | Valley Rd |
| 66 | Alt 630 | Vauxhall Rd |
| 67 | 607 | Walnut St - see 61A |
| 68 | 671 | Washington St |
| 69 | 655 | Watchung Ave - also shown on old pre-Garden State Pkwy stub (now Pilch St) |
| 70 | 622 | West Passaic Ave, Darling Ave |
| 71 | 625 | Hollywood Ave - originally West Fairfield-Clinton Rd |
| 72 | 632 | Westville Ave |
| 73 | 658 | Park Ave - was once NJ 10 and thus likely a late addition, hence the high number |
| 74 | 672 | Mill St - probably a late addition and thus the high number |